SPE Drilling & Completion
Volume 24, Number 4, December 2009, pp. 590-598

SPE-112701-PA

Cement-Slurry Performance and Set-Cement Properties vs. Microsilica Densification

View full textPDF ( 1,138 KB )

DOI  More information 10.2118/112701-PA http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/112701-PA

Citation

  • Daou, F. and Piot, B. 2009. Cement-Slurry Performance and Set-Cement Properties vs. Microsilica Densification. SPE Drill & Compl  24 (4): 590-598. SPE-112701-PA. doi: 10.2118/112701-PA.

Discipline Categories

  • 1 Drilling and Completions
  • 1.4.1 Drilling and Well Control Equipment
  • 1.4.3 Downhole Operations (Casing, Cementing, Coring, Geosteering, Fishing)

Keywords

  • microsilica, cement, densification, particle size, slurry stability

Summary

Microsilica is the extremely fine noncrystalline silica obtained in electric furnaces as a byproduct in the manufacture of elemental silicon and ferrosilicon alloys. This waste material, also improperly called silica fume, is available in different grades of various handling characteristics. It has been used for years as cement admixture both in the oil field and in construction and civil engineering industries. Because of its extremely fine nature and high reactivity as a pozzolanic material, microsilica has been used to improve slurry stability and the mechanical properties of the hardened material.

This paper reviews typical uses of microsilica in oilfield cements. Particular attention is given to the influence of material grade in terms of degree of densification, on slurry behavior, and set cement properties. The physical properties of the tested microsilica include specific gravity, loose and compacted bulk densities, and particle-size distribution before and after being submitted to an ultrasonic treatment. Slurry behavior is evaluated in terms of rheology and stability.

The observation of set microsilica cement microstructure with a scanning electron microscope, coupled with an energy dispersive spectrometer, clarifies the question concerning the dispersability of densified microsilica in cement slurry. An unambiguous correlation between physical properties of microsilica, slurry performance, and set cement stability and morphology is also established, leading the way to correctly specifying the quality of microsilica to be used in oilfield applications.

This work demonstrates that, contrary to common belief, not all grades of microsilica are equal and that densified microsilica does not redisperse into small particles when mixed in a cement slurry. Therefore, densified grades, which are popular for their ease of handling, do not provide the performance required for adequate zonal isolation as is normally expected from microsilica slurry. In particular, densified material improves neither the slurry stability nor the set cement mechanical properties. Only moderately compacted microsilica with a bulk density of approximately 300 kg/m3 have been found to offer the adequate compromise between proper handling characteristics and good slurry and set cement performance.

View full textPDF ( 1,138 KB )

History

  • Original manuscript received: 10 December 2007
  • Meeting paper published: 4 March 2008
  • Revised manuscript received: 19 March 2009
  • Manuscript approved: 15 April 2009
  • Published online: 10 September 2009
  • Version of record: 23 December 2009