SPE Journal
Volume 14, Number 3, September 2009, pp. 413-422

SPE-106030-PA

A Detailed Comparison of Experimental and Numerical Data on Hydraulic Fracture Height Growth Through Stress Contrasts

View full textPDF ( 698 KB )

DOI  More information 10.2118/106030-PA http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/106030-PA

Citation

  • Jeffrey, R.G. and Bunger, A.P. 2009. A Detailed Comparison of Experimental and Numerical Data on Hydraulic Fracture Height Growth Through Stress Contrasts. SPE J.  14 (3): 413-422. SPE-106030-PA. doi: 10.2118/106030-PA.

Discipline Categories

  • 5.3.3 Hydraulic Fracturing and Gravel Packing

Summary

This paper compares height, length, width, and pressure data from a laboratory experiment to predictions from a three-dimensional (3D) planar hydraulic fracture model for the case of a fracture propagating in a lower-stress payzone region bounded by two symmetric higher-stress barrier regions. A laboratory method that creates step-like stress changes on an interface between two transparent polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) blocks is described. A fracture is propagated along this interface while measuring fracture geometry and full-field fracture width (opening) by analysis of the light intensity in images of the growing fracture. The fracture grew in overall height to 1.7 times the pay height and in half-length to 3 times the pay height. Results from a planar 3D numerical model closely matched the experimental data for overall fracture shape, length, height growth, and injection pressure. The data are presented so other numerical models can be compared with these detailed measurements.

Introduction

The development of hydraulic fracturing models that are able to account for height growth started with the introduction of the pseudo 3D approach in the late 1970s (Settari and Cleary 1984) and has continued ever since. Simonson et al. (1978) analyzed height growth by considering a uniformly pressurized fracture cross section growing into symmetrical stress barriers. Stress barriers are recognized to have a strong effect on hydraulic fracture height growth (Warpinski et al. 1982a; Warpinski et al. 1982b; Nolte and Smith 1981). Hydraulic fracture models must be able to demonstrate accurate prediction of fracture height and length evolution, and this paper provides one detailed data set for such verification. An equivalent detailed data set for fracture height growth into stress barriers does not exist in the literature.

Overview of the Method

Laboratory experiments allow for control of the problem parameters to a degree not possible in full-size field experiments. By controlling the parameters, the effect on fracture growth of one aspect of the problem, such as stress contrasts in this experiment, can be studied in detail. The experimental data can then be compared to theoretical and/or numerical predictions to provide the validation of those predictions.

The laboratory method relies on creating step-like stress changes on an interface between two polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) blocks. The stress variations along the interface are produced by machining one surface of one block with a prescribed profile designed so a step in the interface contact stress is produced when this surface is pressed tightly against another, flat, block surface. Results obtained by propagating a fracture along the interface in this lower-stress payzone region bounded by two symmetric higher-stress regions are presented in this paper.

View full textPDF ( 698 KB )

History

  • Original manuscript received: 19 November 2006
  • Meeting paper published: 29 January 2007
  • Revised manuscript received: 11 July 2008
  • Manuscript approved: 29 July 2008
  • Published online: 2 July 2009
  • Version of record: 28 September 2009