SPE Journal
Volume 15, Number 1, March 2010, pp. 146-151

SPE-110497-PA

Estimate of Equation of State Uncertainty for Manometric Sorption Experiments: Case Study With Helium and Carbon Dioxide

View full textPDF ( 421 KB )

DOI  More information 10.2118/110497-PA http://dx.doi.org/10.2118/110497-PA

Citation

  • van Hemert, A.P., Rudolph, E.S.J.,  Bruining, J., and Wolf, K-H.A.A. 2010. Estimate of Equation of State Uncertainty for Manometric Sorption Experiments: Case Study With Helium and Carbon Dioxide . SPE J.  15 (1): 146-151. SPE-110497-PA. doi: 10.2118/110497-PA.

Discipline Categories

  • 6.8 Fundamental Research in Reservoir Description and Dynamics
  • 5.3 Production Enhancement
  • 2.5.1 Global Climate Change/CO2 Capture and Management
  • 6.4.2 Gas-Injection Methods

Summary

The sorption of gases on coal is of great importance for the use of gas injection to enhance coalbed methane production. Furthermore, when injecting carbon dioxide (CO2), the project is eligible for carbon credits as the CO2 is sequestrated.

Accurate measurements of sorption at in-situ conditions have proven to be a complicated matter. Especially, the sorption of CO2, pure or in a mixture, are particularly sensitive to experimental errors, because common in-situ conditions of deep coalbeds are near the critical point of CO2. One source of uncertainty in sorption measurements is the accuracy with which gas densities have been determined. Accurate determinations of gas densities at in-situ conditions are complex and require the inclusion of specialized equipment. Therefore, gas densities are usually calculated from pressure and temperature measurements using an Equation of State (EoS). The accuracy of this EoS then influences the uncertainty in the sorption measurement. Therefore, it is essential that an EoS is used that is most accurate at the experimental conditions. However, there is generally little information available on the accuracy of an EoS for the conditions of interest. This is particularly true for the calculation of densities of mixtures with an EoS.

This paper describes an experimental method to estimate the accuracy of an EoS using a manometric sorption apparatus. This is demonstrated by using He and CO2 at 318.11 K and pressures between 0.1 and 17 MPa, which covers the range of interest for deep coalbeds.

The accuracies of the following EoSs have been estimated: Peng-Robinson with Stryjek-Vera modification for CO2; Peng-Robinson with an alpha parameter proposed by Twu in 1995 for He; multiparameter crossover equation of state by Sun, Kiselev, and Ely for CO2; modified Benedict-Webb-Rubin EoS by McCarty and Arp for He; and the reference EoS for CO2 by Span and Wagner.

The experimental method provides a lower limit estimate of the accuracy for an EoS. This estimate can be used as a first approximation of the EoS accuracy in the a priori error analysis of manometric sorption experiments.

View full textPDF ( 421 KB )

History

  • Original manuscript received: 2 August 2007
  • Meeting paper published: 11 November 2007
  • Revised manuscript received: 17 February 2009
  • Manuscript approved: 17 February 2009
  • Published online: 16 July 2009
  • Version of record: 12 March 2010